If you’ve lived in the Salt Lake Valley for more than a few months, you’ve probably seen the “white crust” on your showerhead or noticed your tap water has a slight “swimming pool” scent. It’s just part of the local charm. Well, not exactly.
Most people know their water needs something, but they get stuck deciding between a water softener and a filtration system. At Plumbing Utah, we see homeowners buy a filter thinking it will save their dishwasher from limescale, or install a softener hoping to get rid of a metallic taste.
The reality? They are two different solutions, each with their own set of benefits. This article is intended to help you understand the difference and what a whole home filtration system, versus a water softener can do you for. By the end you should have a better understanding of which utility is better for you situaiton and why.
The reason we compare these two is simple: Utah water is a double-threat.
Our water is naturally “hard” (high in minerals), which is an infrastructure issue. But it’s also treated with chemicals like chlorine, which pose quality and health problems. A softener adjusts how the water behaves in your pipes; a filter adjusts how the water tastes and feels in your glass.
In Utah, our water is packed with calcium and magnesium. It’s basically liquid rock. A water softener’s only job is to swap those minerals for tiny amounts of salt (ion exchange).
What a Softener is primarily for:
While a softener handles the “rocks,” a filtration system handles the ” chemicals.”” Even if your water is soft, it might still contain chlorine, lead, or sediment you don’t want to drink or cook with.
What Filtration is primarily for:
If you see/feel… | You likely need a… | Because… |
White spots on dishes | Water softener | It’s caused by mineral deposits |
A “bleach” or pool smell | Water filtration | It’s caused by chlorine treatment |
Itchy, dry skin | Water softener | Minerals prevent soap from rinsing off. |
Metallic or bitter taste | Water filtration | It’s caused by contaminants or old pipes. |
The “right” choice isn’t a toss-up; it’s based on your priorities.
If you just moved into a brand-new home and want to keep your plumbing pristine for twenty years, start with a softener. If you’re more worried about what your kids are drinking and want the best-tasting ice cubes in the neighborhood, start with a filtration system.
Honestly? In many parts of Utah, the “gold standard” is a hybrid approach. Using a softener to protect your home’s pipes while using a Reverse Osmosis (RO) system under the kitchen sink for drinking water is the most popular setup for a reason—it solves both sides of the Utah water equation.
Still not sure what’s flowing through your pipes? Don’t guess. We can run a quick water test to tell you exactly how many “grains” of hardness you have and what your chlorine levels look like.
Give Plumbing Utah a call (801) 601-1298 and let’s figure out a system that actually makes sense for your house.
Call Today
If you’ve ever caught a whiff of something “off” while standing over your kitchen sink, you aren’t alone. It’s one of the most common complaints
If you’ve lived in the Salt Lake Valley for more than a few months, you’ve probably seen the “white crust” on your showerhead or noticed
There is a timeless appeal to the 1950s ramblers found throughout the Salt Lake Valley. From the tree-lined streets of Sugar House to the sturdy